5 Claymill Rd, Leicester LE4 9JJ
Mob: 07707 753378
info@masjidmuhammad.uk
Question:
A person has not performed his own hajj, and wants to go for hajj-ebadal.
Is it makruh for him to go? If it is, then is it makruh tahrimi or
makrBh tanzihi?
Answer:
It is best for the person who wants to perform hajj-e-badal to have
already performed his own hajj. However, this is not a prerequisite nor
is it essential. Yes, if hajj is already obligatory on the one who has been
asked to perform hajj-e-badal, then it is makrBh tahrimi for him to
perform hajj-e-badal, and makrBh tanzihi for the one who asks him.
Allah ta‛ala know best.